Welcome to our SeaFall designer notes! Thanks to Rob for giving us an early glimpse into the world of SeaFall - without spoilers, of course! SeaFall: A Legacy Game is available for pre-order at the store. Pre-orders of SeaFall from receive a full set of over 100 upgraded metal coins. US orders over $100 are eligible for free shipping.

I wanted adventure.

It was fall of 2012. I had left Hasbro the month before. Risk Legacy was a surprise success and, for the first time in 14 years as a professional game designer, I could make any game I wanted to.

I wanted adventure. I wanted the open sea, unknown islands, maps, charts, lost tombs, and a sense that something big was just over the horizon. I wanted lost treasures and naval battles and a race back to port to win the day. I wanted a game that I could show to my 12 year-old self and know that he would fall in love with it.

As I told someone, “I want Indiana Jones in the Age of Sail.”

Antique Statue

For the most part, that’s what SeaFall is. It’s part Euro game, part Ameritrash at its finest. It has a twisting emergent story, legacy-style play, and a lot of twists and turns as players explore the seas to discover how they can bring glory to their province.


SeaFall is a 3-5 player legacy game. It is competitive. Not as cutthroat as Risk, but it has its moments of treachery. Each player is a ruler of a province and the goal for each game is to attain glory. Reach the target glory before any other player and you win the game. Players play the same province for the entire length of the campaign. The fate of your province – and its impact on the world – is yours and yours alone. Glory is tracked from game to game and the player who has the most glory when the end of the world is discovered becomes the Emperor (or Empress) who reunites the provinces at long last.

Prince/Princess of the Realm

Very early on, I established the main actions you could do on your turn – raid/fight, explore, trade, or build. These stayed constant through its design and development. With those goals I set off on a three year journey of design, redesign, testing, and more testing. The game changed a lot – a lot lot lot – in those 3.5 years. At first, the game was all about ships. Each player had two to four ships plying the seas. But some early feedback showed that players wanted more than a flotilla. So I added some lands to rule… and protect. On these provinces, you could have buildings, treasure rooms, fields, and other little aspects to your province that made it unique.  You had a home and your ships were setting sail from there.

SeaFall set-up 

Every week for the next few months, I will have a design note about an aspect of the game, explaining how it works, why it's there, and how I hope you have fun with it. Being a legacy game, I can’t get into everything – there are unknowns best left for you to discover yourself. My hope with these articles is that you can learn enough of the game so that reading the rulebook is short and simple and you can start playing quickly.

Here is what the next ten weeks will feature.

  1. Provinces – all the parts of your domain
  2. Game Structure  – what you do on a turn
  3. The Merchants Guild – buying and selling goods
  4. The Builders Guild – building structures and improving ships
  5. Dice Pools and Endeavors – how the unknown is resolved
  6. The Explorers Guild & The Captain’s Booke – what is out there on those islands?
  7. The Soldiers Guild & Enmity – how to raid, tax, and leave lasting hatred
  8. Advisors – they make everything better
  9. Legacy Aspects – what changes from game to game and how milestones drive it forward
  10. A developer’s view (this one is going to be written by SeaFall’s developer, JR Honeycutt)

Adventure awaits. The seas await. Destiny awaits.

Glory awaits.

Sealed card

SeaFall Links

Come back to every Tuesday for a new SeaFall preview! SeaFall: A Legacy Game is available for pre-order at the store. Pre-orders of SeaFall from receive a full set of over 100 upgraded metal coins. US orders over $100 are eligible for free shipping.


Smitty commented:

This game has been a must-buy for me ever since its announcement. Would anyone who's played it know if having one player via skype would be feasible? Reading over the rules, it doesn't look like there's any hidden player-specific information (e.g. a hand of cards), though of course that could change. But otherwise, if a remote player could see the board and have people roll dice for him, could that feasibly work?

Posted on 2016-05-18.

Joshua Geimer commented:

Rob, it's been such a pleasure listening back over your many Designers Round Table podcasts and hearing the process you went through to get to this point. I'm looking forward to reading through these new posts to continue getting a closer look at the development of this amazing endeavor. Thank you for offering this content! Hoping to get the cash together soon to pre-order.

Posted on 2016-05-18.

jayelbird commented:

Smitty, I don't think its going to work. First, there are the advisors, and you may want to keep the advisors you have hidden until you reveal them. But there may be other information that comes later that might not be quite as conducive, based of the playtest.

Posted on 2016-05-18.

Smitty commented:

Thanks, jayelbird. It didn't occur to me that players would keep their advisors hidden, but that makes sense. And the later information you reference, good to know, thank you.

Posted on 2016-05-19.

You must be registered for our forums and logged in to leave a comment.